Beyond Emergy Algebra: Corrado Giannantoni and the Mathematics of Self-Organization

What follows grew out of my attempt over the past year or so to better understand Corrado Giannantoni’s contributions. I first met Corrado in 1993 at an Italian emergy workshop. He was an unassuming man with an intellectual intensity matched by few people I have known, and I often had the feeling that he understood something important that the rest of us were missing.

I cannot say that I fully understand everything he was proposing. But after studying his work in greater detail, I think I now have a much better sense of what he was trying to accomplish. His research examined the mathematical foundations of emergy algebra and the Maximum Empower Principle and, increasingly, what those foundations might tell us about self-organization.

What began as an effort to give Maximum Empower a mathematical formulation eventually became something considerably broader: an attempt to develop a mathematics capable of representing not only change within a system, but the generation of new organization.

The Problem Hidden in Emergy Algebra

Giannantoni’s research examined the mathematical implications of the rules of emergy algebra, particularly those governing co-production, interaction, and feedback.

A fundamental distinction emerged between transfer and generation. A split transfers something already present among different pathways. Co-production, interaction, and feedback are different. In Giannantoni’s terminology, they became Rules of Genesis of Ordinality, while the first rule and the split rule became Rules of Transfer of Ordinality.

Co-production illustrates the distinction. When a process produces two or more co-products, the emergy supporting the process is not divided among them. The total emergy is assigned to each because each requires the entire process that generated it. Mathematical analysis of this rule identified a mismatch between what the rule asserts and its representation using conventional mathematical equality.

The issue therefore went beyond the mechanics of emergy accounting. Co-production, interaction, and feedback appeared to represent processes in which something arises that was not present in the same form before. If so, the question was whether mathematics designed primarily to describe quantities and changes in those quantities could adequately represent generation.

That question became the central thread running through much of Giannantoni’s subsequent work.

From Change to Becoming

The initial objective was to formulate the Maximum Empower Principle mathematically. Papers presented at the Emergy Synthesis conferences in 1999 and 2001 developed mathematical definitions of emergy and the emergy balance equation toward that objective. But the 2001 work also introduced a concept that would lead in a different direction: the incipient derivative.

A conventional derivative describes how one quantity changes with respect to another—for example, how the amount stored in a system changes with time. The incipient derivative was intended to represent something different: a process in its “rising” or “incipient” act of being born.

The word incipient is important. The mathematical problem was no longer simply how an already defined quantity changes through time, but how to represent the process through which a new condition arises.

Applied to co-production, interaction, and feedback, the incipient derivative provided a common mathematical representation for processes regarded as generative. This led first to the concept of Quality and subsequently to Ordinality.

Giannantoni’s use of Quality was somewhat different from its familiar use in emergy theory. In emergy, energy quality refers to differences among forms of energy in their ability to contribute to work, commonly expressed through transformity. Giannantoni used Quality more broadly to refer to something arising through a generative process that could not be adequately represented solely by the quantities entering that process. He initially related this idea to transformity, distinguishing the dissipation of available energy from what he called generative transformity, representing the increase in Quality associated with the generative process. 

The concept subsequently developed into Ordinality. I find it useful to think of Ordinality as concerned with relationships and organization rather than simply quantity. Co-production, interaction, and feedback establish different kinds of relationships. Co-production relates a common process to two or more products; interaction brings different inputs together in producing an output; and feedback returns part of the result to influence the process that produced it. Their structures differ, yet each involves the generation of relationships that were not present in the same form beforehand.

The common property underlying these processes was termed Generativity.

The research had therefore moved beyond the original question of how to formulate Maximum Empower. It was approaching a more general problem: how can mathematics represent the coming into being of organization?

From Maximum Empower to Maximum Ordinality

The next step was to extend Generativity from individual processes to the system as a whole. A single generative process is not equivalent to the development of an organized system. In a self-organizing system, many processes are linked: products become inputs to other processes, structures alter subsequent transformations, and feedbacks influence what happens next.

A growing tree provides a useful example. Photosynthesis transforms inputs into sugars, but sugar is not a tree. Those products support other transformations that produce roots, stems, leaves, and other structures. Those structures, in turn, make possible additional transformations and greater capture of sunlight, water, and nutrients. Feedbacks connect these processes and influence their subsequent development. No single transformation generates the tree. The tree develops through the interconnected operation of many processes.

This is where Ordinality becomes particularly important. It is not simply a measure of the number of components or interactions in a system. In Giannantoni’s formulation, each part is related to the others because it is, first of all, ordered to the Whole. The relationships among roots, leaves, stems, and the processes occurring within them therefore acquire their significance not simply as individual relationships but through their place in the functioning tree.

By 2010 this line of reasoning had led to the Maximum Ordinality Principle:

“Every System tends to Maximize its own Ordinality, including that of the surrounding habitat.”

The statement is not easy to understand by itself. In the context of the preceding work, however, its intent becomes clearer. Self-organization involves more than maximizing a quantity. Through interconnected generative processes, relationships develop among the components of a system and between the system and its surroundings, progressively organizing the system as a whole.

This also helps explain the proposed relationship between Maximum Ordinality and Maximum Empower. Maximum Empower is expressed in terms of emergy and empower. Maximum Ordinality attempts to describe the generative development of a self-organizing system without requiring those quantities as its starting point. What began as an effort to provide a mathematical formulation of Maximum Empower had thus become an attempt to formulate a more general principle of self-organization.

Beyond Emergy

Once formulated in these terms, the approach was no longer limited to emergy. The incipient derivative, Generativity, and Ordinality were applied to questions in mechanics, physics, chemistry, biology, economics, and other complex systems. 

The claims made in this later work extend well beyond emergy and into fundamental questions concerning mathematics, physics, and scientific explanation. I am not in a position to judge those claims. What is important here is the intellectual path that led to them. It began with the mathematical implications of several unusual rules used in emergy analysis. Those rules raised a distinction between transfer and generation, which led to the incipient derivative, Generativity, and Ordinality, and ultimately to an attempt to develop a more general mathematics of self-organization.

Why Corrado’s Work Matters

The reason I kept coming back to Corrado’s work was that he seemed to be getting at something that had bothered me for a long time. We cannot generally predict what new component, pathway, process, or relationship might arise as a system self-organizes. In essence, we remain confined by the system we have already defined.

Self-organization is not simply a change in the magnitude of state variables. The Maximum Empower Principle suggests systems will continue to reorganize through selection of configurations that increase empower. But it does not tell us what that reorganization will look like.

This is what now draws me most strongly to Corrado’s work. I cannot say whether his Incipient Differential Calculus provides the mathematics needed to overcome this limitation. I am not sufficiently knowledgeable in mathematics to make that judgment. But I think I finally understand the problem he was trying to address.

Looking back, that may also explain why I remained interested in Corrado’s work even when I understood so little of the mathematics. He seemed to be reaching beyond a mathematics of change toward a mathematics capable of describing becoming.

Whether he succeeded is a question I will leave to others. But I think the problem he was addressing is an important one.

Key Writings by Corrado Giannantoni

Toward a Mathematical Formulation of the Maximum Em-Power Principle — Corrado Giannantoni (1999)

Mathematical Formulation of the Maximum Em-Power Principle — Corrado Giannantoni (2001) 

Mathematics for Quality: Living and Non-Living Systems — Corrado Giannantoni (2001) 

Differential Bases of Emergy Algebra — Corrado Giannantoni (2004) 

Emergy Analysis as the First Ordinal Theory of Complex Systems — Corrado Giannantoni (2006) 

From Transformity to Ordinality, or better: From Generative Transformity to Ordinal Generativity — Corrado Giannantoni (2008) 

The Maximum Ordinality Principle: A Harmonious Dissonance — Corrado Giannantoni (2010) 

The Relevance of Emerging Solutions for Thinking, Decision Making and Acting: The Case of Smart Grids — Corrado Giannantoni (2012) 

Toward One Sole Reference Principle Generating “Emerging Solutions” of Progressively Ascending Ordinality — Corrado Giannantoni (2014)

The “Emerging Quality” of Self-Organizing Systems, When Modeled According to the Maximum Ordinality Principle, Offers a Radically New Perspective to Modern Science — Corrado Giannantoni (2016)

Self-Organizing Systems, When Modeled According to the Maximum Ordinality Principle, Always Present Explicit Formal Solutions, in Their Proper Time and Proper Space — Corrado Giannantoni (2018) 

The Evolution of the Universe as a Self-Organizing System in the Light of the Maximum Ordinality Principle, in the Absence of “Dark Energy” and “Dark Matter” — Corrado Giannantoni (2020)